DavesRepair.com
   Appliance Repair Help for the 'Handy' from a 40-year Tech! 
   Free Repair Tips, Articles, and Links to Parts at Wholesale


 

 

 

 

 

Home
Contact me
Disclaimer   
(Read First!)

Wholesale Parts!
Vintage Parts

Manuals:
Index
Ampex
GM Frigidaire
Maytag
McIntosh
Speed Queen
Sunbeam
Westinghouse
Whirlpool/KM

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)


My Guarantee

What Customers are saying...

How-to Articles 

Newsletter
Back issues

Dave's Dictionary of Appliance Terms

Garage Door Nation
(Springs, Parts, DIY)

Has my website been helpful?

Free pdf Readers:



Did you Know? 
You no longer need a Paypal account to make payments using your credit card!


Favorite Links

Site Map
A Gift for You


Website owner: 
Dave Harnish
CEO: Sadie
Dave's Repair Service
1911 Heath Hill Rd
New Albany, PA 18833
Email:
drs@sosbbs.com


Psalm 118:8


 

 

 

Official PayPal Seal

The DRSNews
April 2005
(Think Spring!)


In this issue:
1) Why I Don't Recommend Front Load Washers (yet)
2) 'Tall Tub' Dishwashers - Worth the Extra Bucks? [Updated Fall '21]

1) I get asked about front load washers nearly every day, so I though I'd share my $.02 on the subject with you. Especially since I've already had to 'DOA' two more this month, and I'm writing this on the 6th! I hate telling folks to scrap these beautiful-looking machines!

First, the positives: for the most part, these machines do a good job of washing clothes, using little water and detergent. They're very easy on fabric while deep-cleaning the toughest stains. 

However: 
I'm seeing American-made front loaders' main bearings lasting only 5-7 years, and that's just not long enough (I don't see enough 'offshore' brand machines - Asko, Miele, etc - to know much about their reliability).

It's tough to fix this inherent weakness, and it's the number one reason (of several) that I can't recommend these machines. 

Here's the problem: When you hang 40-50 pounds of water, laundry, and basket out on the end of a rotating shaft supported by bearings pressed into plastic, you have a mechanical system that just can't survive very long. 

Other problems include leakage at the seam between the two (plastic) tank halves, basket pulley failure, usually resulting in tub wear-through and leaks, and motor (3 phase) controller circuit board failures, just to name a few of the most common. 

Considering the extra cost of one of these washers, 5-7 years just isn't a sound investment. And we won't even go into the electronics problems we have with them out here in the 'boonies' from electrical power that's anything but 'clean' and reliable. Or voltage 'spikes' from nearby lightning strikes... 

There is one bright spot on the horizon, but it's too early for me to tell you if it'll dawn or not. A company in Groveport, Ohio, Staber Corp, entered the residential front loader market a few years ago, and their machines look promising. 

They address the bearing problems by supporting their wash tub with bearings in both front and rear - a major improvement.

Technically not front-loaders (they load from the top), these are what we call 'horizontal axis' machines, because the tub rotates horizontally like a typical FL, and your dryer. Unique.

Even though it appears they're using electronics driving a 3 phase motor like the others, this is one to watch. Not inexpensive, but they should last longer than the comon FL machines. Check them out: www.staber.com

2) I might as well sound off on another newer attempt in the never-ending quest to get you to dig deeper into your wallet: 'tall tub' dishwashers. 

These machines sell themselves as soon as you open their door. All that interior space is a definite 'Wow!' factor, and the door panel reaching nearly to the floor really presents a nice clean look on the outside. 

But once again, after servicing a ton of these, I have to say I'm not yet 'sold'. I'm honestly not a negative person, but... 

Some of the same reservations I have about FL clothes washers apply here. Nearly all these high-end dishwashers use electronic controls, and that adds another level of complexity, which translates into your seeing more of guys like me. (Yes I know, I should be happy to have the extra work, but... <g>) 

The TT's all use a horizontal axis wash pump system to get the necessary extra floor clearance. I repaired dishwashers for some 45 years and have yet to see a horizontally mounted motor/pump assembly that lasted as long as one that's vertically mounted. The weird thing is, I'm not sure why. 

Logically, a pump impeller rotating around a horizontal shaft should be more efficient at 'throwing' water upward. But long term reliability tends to favor the opposite. Odd. As with any newer designs, time will tell. 

Update Fall 2021: The above dates me as a dinosaur, I know. At this point I'm not sure there are *any* vertical axis dishwashers being built any longer; everyone's gone to tall-tubs. I stand by my statements above, but as with most appliances today, budget for your next machine in less than a decade.

***

"God grant me the serenity to accept the people I cannot change, 
the courage to change the one I can, and the wisdom to know... it's ME!" 

Revelation 22:12-14 KJV

***

Copyright www.DavesRepair.com 
Articles may be reprinted and distributed freely 
only in their entirety, including this message. 

 

 


"Nothing astonishes men so much as common sense and plain dealing" - Ralph Waldo Emerson

Sign up for PayPal and start accepting credit card payments instantly.

Home | Site Map | Contact me | Parts Specials | Laundry Manuals  
Vintage Appliance Parts | McIntosh Manuals | Ampex Manuals | DIY Article Index
| Marketing Resources
 

 
 

All Content on This Website is
Dave's Repair Service
New Albany, PA
All Rights Reserved
Nehemiah 9:6